Composite Wood Fencing vs. Traditional Wood: What’s the Best Choice for You?
Choosing the right fence material can feel overwhelming. Should you go with the timeless charm of traditional wood or the modern durability of composite wood fencing?
Both have their perks and downsides, and the answer of composite wood fencing vs. traditional wood depends on what’s most important to you—cost, maintenance, durability, or even sustainability.
After spending years relying on traditional wood fences at all of our previous homes, we decided to try something new with our latest project: a composite wood fence. The worn-out chain link fence in our backyard desperately needed a replacement, especially after we spent all spring transforming our patio space.
So, let’s dive into the pros and cons of composite wood fencing vs. traditional wood to help you make the best choice for your home.
Composite Wood Fencing vs. Traditional Wood
Composite Wood Fencing vs. Traditional Wood: How Do They Compare?
Cost: Composite Wood Fence Cost vs. Traditional Wood
Here’s the deal: composite fences cost more upfront, but that higher price comes with a payoff. They require far less maintenance and last longer, saving you money in the long run. Traditional wood fences are more budget-friendly at first but come with ongoing costs for staining, sealing, and repairs.
Think of it like this: traditional wood is a short-term investment, while composite wood is the set-it-and-forget-it option.
Durability: Composite vs. Wood Fence Durability
How long do composite fences last compared to wood? Composite fences typically last 25–30 years, while wood fences might give you 15–20 years if you’re lucky (and diligent with maintenance).
Wood fences, especially those made from cedar or redwood, naturally resist rot and insects but still can’t compete with the weather-resistant properties of composite fencing. Composite fences won’t warp, crack, or fall victim to wood rot, even in tough climates.
Maintenance: Requirements for Composite vs. Wood Fence
This is where composite wood really shines. Unlike wood, which requires staining, sealing, and repairs, composite fences only need occasional cleaning with soap and water.
Wood fencing looks stunning when it’s freshly stained, but let’s be honest—it’s a pain to keep it that way. If you’d rather spend your weekends relaxing instead of re-staining or pressure washing, composite might be the way to go.
Weather Resistance:
Composite fences are UV-resistant (no fading!), rot-proof, and don’t warp in extreme heat or cold. Traditional wood fences can hold their own in mild conditions, but prolonged exposure to rain or intense sun can lead to problems like cracking, splintering, and—you guessed it—wood rot. For us in hurricane territory, the weather resistance column is definitely important!
Aesthetic Appeal: Color Options for Fencing
Love the natural look of wood? Same. It’s beautiful and can be stained or painted in almost any color you want. Composite fencing, however, has stepped up its game and is no longer the acrylic-looking white only. Brands like Trex offer options that mimic real wood grain, and they come in a variety of colors that stay vibrant without any upkeep.
Is Composite Fencing Better Than Wood?
It depends on what you’re looking for:
- If you want a fence that’s low-maintenance, durable, and eco-friendly, composite fencing is the better choice.
- If you prefer a classic look with a lower upfront cost, traditional wood fencing might be the way to go.
Fence Installation: DIY or Professional?
Whether you choose composite or wood, the installation is fairly similar in that you’ll dig holes, install posts, and put up the board.
DIY fence installation is possible for both, but composite fences can be a bit trickier due to their weight (we were thiiiissss close to a marital spat trying to hoist up the composite fence gate).
Professional fence installation ensures everything is done right the first time, which can save you headaches (and money) later, but of course is going to cost more upfront.
Final Thoughts
Deciding between composite wood fencing vs. traditional wood comes down to what matters most to you. Want a fence that’s durable, weather-resistant, and eco-friendly? Composite is a no-brainer. Prefer a more affordable option with natural charm? Traditional wood has you covered. For reference, here’s the composite wood one we used & love.
Whatever you choose, your new fence will add beauty, privacy, and value to your home—making it a project well worth the investment. It made such a difference in our backyard and gave us so much privacy.
If you enjoyed this post about composite wood fencing vs. traditional wood, sign up to our newsletter where we share all of our favorite DIY updates and follow along on Instagram.
