Rubber Mulch vs. Wood Mulch: Which Is Better for Your Garden?
When planning my front yard landscaping makeover, I spent a lot of time comparing rubber mulch vs. wood mulch to find the best option for our DIY project. Each has unique benefits depending on what you’re looking for in terms of durability, aesthetics, curb appeal and environmental impact.
Through my research about rubber mulch vs. wood mulch, I weighed the pros and cons of both to make the right choice for my garden, and here’s what went into the choice.
Rubber Mulch vs. Wood Mulch: The Landscaping Debate
When it comes to landscaping, rubber mulch vs. wood mulch is a long debated topic as each bring something different to the table.
Rubber mulch is tough and long-lasting, perfect for backyard playgrounds or high-traffic areas. You won’t need to replace it often, and it stays put even on slopes or during heavy rain.
Wood mulch, on the other hand, has a natural look and decomposes over time, which adds nutrients to your soil—an important benefit for those focused on the health of their plants.
Weed Control, Erosion, and Pests: Which Mulch Wins?
If you’re battling weeds, rubber mulch has the upper hand because it creates a dense barrier that blocks sunlight. Both mulches are effective to a degree, though you’ll want to add a weed barrier underneath rubber mulch for extra protection, which is what we did in our flower bed.
When it comes to erosion control, rubber mulch also wins, as its heavier weight keeps it in place better than wood mulch during storms. Products like mulch glue are also effective for keeping mulch from blowing away in the wind.
If you’re worried about pests, rubber mulch again stands out—it doesn’t attract termites, ants, or other bugs that often hide in wood mulch.
Durability, Cost, and Maintenance: What’s More Practical?
In terms of cost, it’s all about what matters most to you—short-term savings or long-term investment.
Wood mulch is cheaper upfront, but it decomposes, so you’ll be replacing it every year or two. Rubber mulch, while more expensive initially, lasts a lot longer (up to 10 years).
A pro for wood mulch is that it insulates better because it’s more lightweight and lets in more light, and rubber mulch can retain heat, which might stress plants in hotter climates.
If you’re looking for low-maintenance, rubber mulch is the clear winner. You won’t have to worry about replacing or refreshing it as often as wood mulch. Cost was one of the biggest factors we weighed when deciding rubber mulch vs. wood mulch, but we still opted for the more expensive upfront costs.
Both mulch types require the same landscaping tools for installation.
Soil Health, Safety, and Environmental Impact
One of the key benefits of wood mulch is that it breaks down naturally, enriching your soil with organic matter and improving fertility over time. This makes it a great option for flower and vegetable gardens where soil health is a priority.
On the other hand, rubber mulch doesn’t decompose or add nutrients to the soil, making it less ideal for plants that rely on organic material for growth.
From an environmental perspective, rubber mulch repurposes old tires, keeping them out of landfills, which is a positive aspect of its use. However, there are some concerns about the possibility of chemical leaching from rubber mulch into the soil over time, although research is still inconclusive on its long-term effects.
Fire Safety, Soil pH, and Odor
Fire safety might be a bigger concern than you’d expect. Surprisingly, rubber mulch is less flammable than dry wood mulch, though it can still ignite. In fact, during heat waves mulch was even catching on fire.
As for soil pH, wood mulch may slightly acidify your soil as it breaks down, while rubber mulch doesn’t affect soil chemistry at all. I won’t pretend to be a green thumb, so do your own research on this.
When it comes to odor, fresh wood mulch has that natural, earthy smell many people love. Rubber mulch, on the other hand, can give off a slight odor, especially on hot days, but this tends to fade over time. We noticed the rubber-y smell for maybe 48 hours but haven’t noticed it again since.
Color and Aesthetic Preferences
Both types of mulch come in a variety of colors. Rubber mulch offers vibrant, long-lasting color choices, which won’t fade as quickly as wood mulch. However, if you prefer a more natural look, wood mulch provides the authentic tones that fit seamlessly into garden settings.
We opted for a common brown mulch color. Without judging (but kind of judging) let’s stop as a society supporting people who choose red mulch. Black is sometimes acceptable in certain instances.
FAQs: Common Mulch Questions Answered
How often should I replace mulch?
Replace wood mulch every 1-2 years. Rubber mulch can last up to 10 years.
Which mulch is better for weed control?
Rubber mulch tends to block weeds better because it doesn’t break down as quickly.
Is rubber mulch safe for playgrounds?
Yes, rubber mulch is commonly used in backyard playgrounds because of its soft, cushioning properties and safety benefits. So if you’re considering a playground around your home, you’re good with either option.
Does rubber mulch affect soil health?
Rubber mulch does not improve soil health, whereas wood mulch improves soil as it decomposes. There are differing opinions on the negative impacts of rubber mulch on soil contamination, so do your own research and decide.
Conclusion: What Mulch is Right for You?
Both rubber mulch and wood mulch have their strengths. Rubber mulch is best for durability, low maintenance, and areas prone to erosion or high foot traffic. Wood mulch is the better choice if you’re prioritizing soil health and a natural look. Think about your garden’s specific needs, your maintenance preferences, and your budget to decide which one is the better fit.
If you enjoyed this post about rubber mulch vs. wood mulch, sign up to our newsletter where we share all of our favorite DIY updates and follow along on Instagram.
